OEM & ODM apparel manufacturing since 2004 · Shenzhen, China

Factory Audit Types: BSCI, Sedex, WRAP and What Each Proves

What amfori BSCI, Sedex SMETA and WRAP each cover, how they are graded or certified, how long they remain useful, and what a report can and…

Factory Audit Types: BSCI, Sedex, WRAP and What Each Proves

Answer first: amfori BSCI, Sedex SMETA and WRAP are three different tools. BSCI is a social-compliance audit with an A-to-E rating; amfori states it is not a certification. SMETA is an audit methodology stewarded by Sedex that assesses labour, health and safety, and, in a 4-pillar audit, environment and business ethics, and issues a corrective action plan rather than a letter grade. WRAP is a facility certification against 12 Principles, issued for one year after corrective actions are verified. A report or certificate describes the audited site at a point in time. It does not by itself prove that a garment, a cotton bale or a subcontractor is compliant.

This article compares scope, grading, validity and buyer use, using official scheme documents fetched on 13 November 2026. It complements our earlier guide to what ethical audits in China prove and what they miss. It does not publish Finetex audit scores or certificate numbers. Finetex’s sustainability page states that BSCI and Sedex audit reports are available for supplier onboarding, covering wages, working hours and factory safety. We do not state a WRAP certification on that page, so none is claimed here.

What each scheme actually is

The three names are often used as if they were interchangeable “social certificates.” They are not.

amfori BSCI (Business Social Compliance Initiative) is a member-based social risk-management system. Auditors assess a site against 81 questions using on-site observation, interviews and document review. Each question is rated Yes, No, Partial or Not applicable, and the report carries an overall grade from A to E. The questions map to 13 Performance Areas in the amfori BSCI Code of Conduct, grouped around social management and workplace relations, employee well-being, protection of vulnerable workers, and ethical practices (including environment and ethical business behaviour). amfori’s own FAQ is explicit: “Is amfori BSCI a certification? No.” There is no pass-or-fail verdict; members are expected to use the report for continuous improvement. Full reports sit on the amfori Sustainability Platform and are visible to members and the audited supplier, not as a public consumer label.

SMETA (Sedex Members Ethical Trade Audit) is, in Sedex’s words, a social audit that helps a business understand labour, health and safety, environmental performance and ethics at its own operations or at a supplier site. Sedex owns the methodology; it does not carry out the audits itself. Only named Affiliate Audit Companies (AACs) and their auditors are approved to use SMETA. Every SMETA audit assesses Labour Standards and Health and Safety, the two founding pillars. A 4-pillar audit adds Environment and Business Ethics. Sedex’s SMETA page, read on 13 November 2026, says most buyers now choose the 4-pillar audit, “used in around 70% of SMETA audits today.” The site is given a Corrective Action Plan (CAP) to close findings. Sedex’s public page does not publish an A-to-E grade for SMETA.

WRAP (Worldwide Responsible Accredited Production) is an independent certification programme focused on the sewn-products and soft-goods sectors. Facilities are assessed against WRAP’s 12 Principles, which WRAP states are based on international workplace standards and local law, and include customs compliance and security (Principle 12 is benchmarked against CBP’s CTPAT programme). Certification is granted only after non-compliances have been corrected and verified. WRAP certificates can be granted only to individual production units; holding companies, brands and retailers are not eligible. WRAP is not a consumer-facing labelling scheme for garments.

Featureamfori BSCISedex SMETAWRAP
What it isSocial audit in a member system; not a certificationSocial audit methodology; findings plus a CAPFacility certification
Who is assessedThe production site (business partner)The individual siteThe individual production unit only
Core scope13 Performance Areas, 81 questionsLabour and health & safety; 4-pillar adds environment and business ethics12 Principles, including customs and security
OutcomeOverall grade A to E, plus findingsReport and Corrective Action Plan; no letter grade on Sedex’s public pageCertificate of Compliance after CAP verification
Who can see itamfori members and the audited supplier on the platformSedex members with whom the report is sharedCertification can be checked; garment tagging is not offered by WRAP
Also check:  DTG vs Screen Printing for Your Brand: Decide by Order Size, Not Hype

Grades, and what the letters actually mean

Only BSCI, among these three, publishes a letter rating in its system manual.

The amfori BSCI System Manual, Part 2 (English, document dated in this fetch to a March 2026 file modification) sets the overall rating as follows:

Overall ratingBandWhat the manual says follows
A — Very Good86% to 100%Continuous improvement without a professional follow-up monitoring
B — Good71% to 85%Continuous improvement without a professional follow-up monitoring
C — Acceptable51% to 70%Improvement plan within 60 days; professional follow-up envisaged
D — Insufficient30% to 50%Improvement plan within 60 days; professional follow-up envisaged
E — Unacceptable0% to 29%Improvement plan within 60 days; professional follow-up envisaged

The overall rating is generated automatically by the amfori IT system from the 13 Performance Areas. The monitoring person does not know the rating and does not present it at the closing meeting. Crucial questions in child labour, bonded and forced labour, and occupational health and safety have the greatest impact. A grade of A is not a claim that no issue exists; it is a maturity rating under this methodology.

SMETA does not use that scale. Buyers should read the findings, the CAP and whether non-compliances have been closed, not look for a BSCI-style letter on a SMETA report.

WRAP, until 1 March 2026, issued certificates at Gold and Platinum levels, with Platinum carrying a two-year term. WRAP’s update of 1 March 2026 states that it will no longer issue two-year (Platinum) certificates, and that certificates will no longer have Gold/Platinum levels. Upon passing the audit, facilities receive a certificate that indicates an annual Certification of Compliance. Existing Platinum certificates remain valid through their current expiration dates. Do not read an older Gold or Platinum certificate as if the current programme still issued those levels.

Validity: how long a report remains useful

BSCI. The audit cycle is two years between full audits. If the overall rating is A or B, validity is 24 months and the next event is a full audit; no follow-up monitoring is required by the rating. If the rating is C, D or E, validity is 12 months after the full audit, and a follow-up may be conducted between two and 12 months later. Completing that follow-up extends validity until the end of the two-year cycle. The follow-up does not re-ask all 81 questions; it focuses on the areas that needed improvement, with a minimum due diligence check on Performance Areas 5, 6 and 7 (fair remuneration, working hours, and occupational health and safety). amfori recommends that follow-up take place about two to three months after the full audit, to leave time for real improvement.

SMETA. Sedex’s published consultation decision is that it will “no longer accept SMETA audits as a robust assessment of current workplace conditions after a period of 24 months.” In the same notice Sedex says its recommendation is that the information within an audit is valid for up to two years, and that this is not a mandate for a two-year cadence. Sedex continues to recommend that high-risk sites (as identified through its risk tools) be audited yearly, medium-risk sites every two years, and low-risk sites at the buyer’s discretion. Announced, semi-announced and unannounced scheduling still exist; Sedex has said it will recommend semi-announced or unannounced audits unless an announced date is needed for a valid logistical reason.

WRAP. WRAP’s certification page states that certifications are valid for one year. All certified facilities are subject to random, unannounced post-certification assessments (PCAs) during the certification period. Prior certification does not ensure renewal, because each audit takes current rules into account.

Also check:  What is the best sweater fabric for comfort and durability: How to Read the Lists (and What They Leave Out)

A report that is still “within date” can still be stale if the site has changed shifts, added a dormitory, switched a process or taken on a new subcontractor. Validity is a scheme rule, not a guarantee of present conditions.

What a report can prove, and what it cannot

A current BSCI report can show how a named site performed against the 13 Performance Areas on the audit dates, including the overall grade and the findings. A current SMETA report can show findings and a CAP for the pillars that were in scope at that site. A current WRAP certificate can show that a named production unit was certified against the 12 Principles for a stated period, after corrective actions were verified.

None of the three, on its own, proves the following:

  • That a specific purchase order or garment is covered. These are site assessments, not product certificates. A WRAP FAQ notes that cloth, buttons or other components may come from a facility that is not WRAP-certified even when final assembly is. The same logic applies to BSCI and SMETA: the sewing unit in the report is not automatically the dye-house, the trim supplier or a subcontracted print shop.
  • That conditions are the same today as on the audit date. Even a 24-month or 12-month validity window is a rule of the scheme, not a continuous camera on the floor.
  • That wages meet a brand’s own living-wage benchmark. BSCI includes a Fair Remuneration performance area, and SMETA assesses labour standards including pay, but a buyer’s private standard may go further than the scheme.
  • That cotton or another input is free of forced labour, or that origin is documented for customs. Social audits and the UFLPA document file answer different questions. A BSCI or SMETA report is not a substitute for origin records.
  • That the brand or the parent group is certified. WRAP will not certify a brand. BSCI and SMETA reports attach to sites, not to a logo.

Buyer use should follow from those limits: ask for the full report (not a first page or an expired PDF), confirm the legal name and address of the site that will actually cut and sew the order, check the date and the follow-up or CAP status, and decide whether environment or business ethics need to be in scope (SMETA 4-pillar, or a separate environmental programme). Use the report to open a conversation about findings, not as a stamp that closes due diligence.

For factory onboarding at Finetex, start from the published about us and sustainability pages, and request the current BSCI and Sedex reports under the conditions described there. Pair the social file with the quality gates on our quality control page and, when a fibre claim is involved, with the transaction-certificate approach set out in our GOTS versus OCS and GRS versus RCS guides. Our clothing factory sourcing guide is the hub for that wider file.

What is fact, what is advice and what is uncertain

Fact (checked 13 November 2026): BSCI’s non-certification status, 81 questions, 13 Performance Areas, A-to-E cycle rules and rating bands come from amfori’s BSCI page and System Manual Part 2. SMETA’s pillars, AAC rule, CAP and the 24-month robustness decision come from Sedex’s SMETA page and consultation notice. WRAP’s facility-only certification, one-year validity, unannounced PCAs and the 1 March 2026 change to an annual Certification of Compliance come from WRAP’s official pages. Finetex’s published statement is limited to BSCI and Sedex reports being available for onboarding.

Advice: the “what it cannot prove” list and the onboarding checks are our practical reading for apparel buyers.

Uncertain: scheme manuals and buyer programmes change. A shared audit may not meet a particular retailer’s additional questions. Always read the current report and the scheme owner’s current documents.

This article is general information and is not legal advice or a substitute for reading the audit report.

Related reading

Also check:  The Seasonal Apparel Buying Calendar for Online Brands

Frequently asked questions

Is a BSCI grade of A or B a certificate?

No. amfori states that BSCI is not a certification and does not deliver a pass-or-fail verdict. A or B means the overall rating fell in the 71% to 100% bands and that, under the system manual, no professional follow-up monitoring is required before the next full audit in the two-year cycle.

What is the difference between a SMETA 2-pillar and 4-pillar audit?

Every SMETA audit covers Labour Standards and Health and Safety. A 4-pillar audit adds Environment and Business Ethics. Sedex’s SMETA page, read on 13 November 2026, says most buyers now choose the 4-pillar option.

How long is a WRAP certificate valid?

WRAP states that certifications are valid for one year. As of 1 March 2026 it no longer issues two-year Platinum certificates or Gold/Platinum levels. Existing Platinum certificates remain valid until their printed expiration dates. Certified facilities remain subject to unannounced post-certification assessments.

If a factory has BSCI, SMETA and WRAP, is the supply chain proven ethical?

No. Each document speaks to the audited site, the scope of that visit, and the date of the visit. It does not automatically cover fabric mills, subcontractors, or a specific shipment, and it does not replace origin or forced-labour documentation.

Can I treat a two-year-old SMETA report as current?

Sedex has said it will no longer accept SMETA audits as a robust assessment of current workplace conditions after 24 months. Even inside that window, Sedex recommends a shorter cadence for higher-risk sites. Read the date, the CAP status and your own risk rating.

Sources

Request the current social-compliance file

Tell us the site, the programme you need to satisfy and the markets you sell in. We will say which current BSCI and Sedex reports we can share for onboarding, and which questions need a follow-up discussion.

Request a quote or start with our about us page.

Keep reading

More factory-floor notes for brand owners

Request a sample & pricing information

Send us your tech pack, target price or a reference sample — we reply with a quotation, a realistic lead time and a fabric recommendation within one working day.

  • Free sampling plan & cost breakdown
  • MOQ from 300 pcs per style
  • Reply within 1 working day
Scroll to Top